Is the ending happy, unhappy, or indeterminate? Is the ending an appropriate ending for this book?
So how does one take down a immortal god-like man and his powerful empire?
By breaking his secret.
The Lord Ruler is just a man, not a god. Well, an immensely powerful man, but there’s a secret to his immortality, to all his power. But how would you ever find it out? This ruler erases all knowledge that opposes him in the land, controlling the people in ways he seems fit. So much was lost to time, but that’s also because the Lord Ruler sought after and killed all those that didn’t worship him.
However, there’s a lot of hints throughout the book that lead to the overall conclusion, and when the pieces are put together, along with some help, causes the entire Final Empire to collapse.
Kelsier’s plan is simple: Gather an army, lead the city’s garrison force outside of the city to deal with another issue far away (also caused by the crew), attack the city with their army of rebels, but not before causing a noble house war with Kelsier assassinating lords in secret and Vin working on the inside by posing as a noblewoman known as “Valette Renoux”. In fact, their whole place of operations is a ruse—They pose as an entire noble house, the house of Lord Renoux. The real Renoux was murdered by Kelsier, and somehow, something that looks exactly like Renoux took its place, working for and with Kelsier. Working on the inside as a less important noble house, they wish to spark a house war, have the city’s garrison leave, then attack with a rebel army in hopes of collapsing the Final Empire, finding and stealing the Lord Ruler’s stockpile of atium, the fuel for the noble house’s economy as well as an extremely rare and powerful metal for Allomancers—one that allows them to see a split-second into the future.
Okay, perhaps it really isn’t simple, in fact it’d likely end in all of them being killed. Forming the rebel army of skaa is the longest part, but it helps that Kelsier is seen as “The Survivor” by the skaa, the Mistborn that had survived “the pits”. Years ago, he had been captured by the Lord Ruler for invading his palace, trying to get into that room which Kelsier believed to hold the Lord Ruler’s atium. He was sent to the pits to work until he died… and something happened there that awoke him: The death of his wife, a Mistborn that was enslaved with him. He realized his Mistborn powers, and with them, he was able to escape—the first person ever to do so. Kelsier is seen highly in the eyes of normal skaa.
Vin, during her time at the house of Renoux, is looked after by a man named Sazed, helping teach her the ways of a noblewoman. As she comes to learn, Sazed is something that calls himself a Feruchemist. Feruchemy is like Allomancy, except rather than drawing powers from metals that Allomancers to, Feruchemists rather use metals to store aspects carried from themselves into the metal, as in, drawing powers from the user. For example, copper, worn on their bodies in the form of bracelets or jewelry, is used to store thoughts and memories, something very important to Sazed as he is a “Keeper”, keeping all kinds of information with him. Other metals are used to store different things too, such as strength, weight, speed, youth, and more by simply reserving that power. Spend awhile incredibly weak, storing that power inside metal, than draw from that power whenever you need it, making you, say, twice as powerful than before. This is what Feruchemists can do—and is the first secret of the Lord Ruler.
During the event where Vin nearly died at the hands of the Steel Inquisitors in Lord Ruler’s palace, she grabbed a book to use as a shield to block incoming daggers flung at her.When Sazed rescued her from dying, he took the book that was with her too. As it turns out, the book is actually a log book written a thousand years ago by the man who is told to be the Hero of Ages, who supposedly later became the Lord Ruler. He seemed like a normal man back then, a good man. How could someone like this become the tyrant that is Lord Ruler? Perhaps something about the power in the well changed him, the power that he was supposed to give up to stop the Deepness, though he kept the power for himself. The Hero of Ages does not give his name in this log, though some people traveling with him were named, most notably Rashek, a Feruchemist packman.
Kelsier also has a secret trick up his sleeve: A fabled 11th metal, which is said to be the secret to killing the Lord Ruler. On his own, Kelsier would meet face to face with the Lord Ruler and use it, hoping that the power from it would somehow be able to kill the god. The legend’s authenticity is questionable, but Kelsier seems determined to use it.
And it all comes down to the end. Most of their amassed army is dead by a mistake, and there seems to be no hope for the plan to go through. But Kelsier never gives up. Maddened with the supposed murder of his brother Marsh, who was working on the insides of Lord Ruler’s obligators, Kelsier returns to the pits where he was once sent year ago, the source of all of nobility’s atium—and destroys all the atium clusters, which won’t regrow for another 300 years or so. In response, Lord Ruler orders another execution to be displayed in the town square of many townsfolk, many innocent, to prove his rule and dominance yet again. But this time, Kelsier attacks. As the prison carts where on their way to the town square, Kelsier intercepts them, killing guards and freeing the prisoners. A Steel Inquisitor is ready for him. Through an intense battle, Kelsier amazingly comes out in the end, beheading the Inquisitor and killing it, something that has never been done before. The town cheers.
And then the Lord Ruler comes.
He steps out of his carriage, almost calmly. He looks like a normal man. Angry townsfolk rush forward, some jab spears in his chest. It’s nothing to him, walking forward like it’s nothing. He walks right up to Kelsier. The two share some short words. “I killed you once.” “You tried, but you can’t kill me, Lord Tyrant. I represent the thing you’ve never been able to kill, no matter how hard you try. I am hope.”
Lord Ruler backhands Kelsier with a powerful blow, the cracking blow heard across the square. Kelsier falls onto the ground, dead, the 11th metal seemingly unused. “Let the executions begin.” Soldiers rush into the crowd and begin slaughtering.
Thing is though, Kelsier planned this all. He planned to die at the Lord Ruler’s hand. Using the game creature that took Lord Renoux’s place, revealed to be a created called a kandra which can eat the body of another to reform as them using their bones and muscles, eats Kelsier’s body in secret and appears to the city’s skaa that night, imitating Kelsier. The skaa see him like a god, and in response, the entire city begins revolting. They may have no army, but with the entire city on their side, they’re seemingly unstoppable.
Vin is given the 11th metal along with a message from Kelsier from the kandra. Vin knows what she must do. With the entire town in chaos and nobility fleeing the city, Vin knows she can strike down now and get into that one room Kelsier always failed to reach in the palace, hoping for the secret to killing the Lord Ruler. Swift as the wind, she invades the palace, and makes her way into that one room, blinding and running past Steel Inquisitors in the process.
Inside the room is… hardly anything. It was all for nothing. Inside the room, however, sits what appears to be an elderly man. The Inquisitors come in and grab her. It’s revealed that this old man is actually Lord Ruler. Vin burns the 11th metal, and an younger man comes up beside the old Lord Ruler, who looked more like the man that killed Kelsier… and another, more wealthier looking man walks up beside Vin. The 11th metal burns out, and those men vanish. It did nothing… and suddenly she is knocked out and captured.
With the help of Sazed, Vin breaks out and works her way up to where Lord Ruler is located. Lord Ruler more looks like his normal, younger self now. Again, she burns the 11th metal, and what appears to be Lord Ruler’s past self appears beside him. Thinking it would work, Vin stabs the past self. Doesn’t work, it doesn’t actually exist, her knife cuts through air. Lord Ruler attacks, and Vin does all she can to survive as she frantically thinks of a way to kill him. His immense power flings her around, somehow pushing and pulling her. It seems hopeless. “God cannot be killed. God cannot be overthrown. Your rebellion—you think I haven’t seen its like before? You think I haven’t destroyed entire armies on my own? What will it take before you people stop questioning? How many centuries must I prove myself before you idiot skaa see the truth? How many of you must I kill?” She burns the 11th metal again, and she sees that same man… in a fur cloak, full beard, and strong muscles. He doesn’t seem at all like the man he is today… he looks, perhaps, like a packman.
This isn’t the Hero of Ages. This was Rashek, from the logs. Vin realizes this, and outs the Lord Ruler for what he really is. He becomes enraged, using his powers to crush Vin against a pillar with incredibly powerful Allomancy. It’s no use, there’s no way she can kill the Lord Ruler, even with that information. If he was really Rashek, then he would be a…
Feruchemist.
The bracelets on his arms, he was drawing power from them. Somehow, this man was both a Feruchemist and an Allomancer, his immortality… was just the Lord Ruler utilizing both powers in a loop, fueling the bracelets with amplified power from burning said stored metals, over and over. He stored youth, he stored strength, everything about him, it was simply the Lord Ruler finding a loophole in his abilities.
Vin, in a fit of rage and near-death from being crushed, pulled against the bracelets impaled in the Lord Ruler’s upper arms… and the mists spun around her, and Vin somehow pulled power from the mists. The bloody bracelets ripped free from the Lord Ruler’s arms and fell near Vin. His eyes widened, rushing towards her. With the last of her strength, she pushed the bracelets over the Lord Ruler’s head and out a broken window. He aged rapidly, collapsing on the floor, dying. Without the immense youth stored in those bracelets, fueling his youth, he would not be able to live long at all. With his last dying breath, he warns that he was their god, even if they couldn’t see it, and by killing him, they’ve all doomed themselves.
Vin tells him a message from her friend: “He’s isn’t dead. He can’t be killed. He is hope.”
And with that, Vin slams a spear right into his heart.
To answer the question… yes, it is a seemingly happy end. The Lord Ruler is dead, the world is now free from his grasp. What they’ve set out to do in the beginning is accomplished, with losses along the way. Everything comes together so well in the end, every detail contributing to the climactic and tense conclusion, and I still had to leave out some details and characters for simplicity.
This book does an amazing job at portraying hopelessness, impossible to solve situations until the last moment. When the hero finally overcomes these massive troubles, the end result is so, so satisfying. The Lord Ruler is built up to be a terrifying man, his presence when he finally shows up to kill Kelsier is just chilling. How Lord Ruler’s powers actually worked was the first book’s biggest mystery, and the solution uses all sorts of hints and clues all throughout the book. And it came down to Vin doing the impossible: Killing the Lord Ruler.
Though, is it truly a happy end? The Lord Ruler may be dead, but there is much work to be done. The chaos will need to be calmed down, the empire will have to be rebuilt from the ground up, and the fear of other attackers trying to take the Lord Ruler’s place. It may be a happy end for now… but who knows what the future holds.
And by reading the second book… things aren’t looking too good.
Sanderson, Brandon. Mistborn – The Final Empire. N.p.: Tom Doherty Associates, 2010. iBooks.